Workflows Foundation .Net 4

I have been making a prototype to evaluate the new incarnation of the Windows Workflow Foundation (WWF 4 beta 1), which will be part of the .Net 4 release. I’m glad of the new changes so far, asynchronous operations are now much easier, and this also applies to activities authoring too. I’m not so happy with the designer, it’s still a bit slow, although it is not an issue for me right now.

Workflow isolation has also been left behind. Running untrusted code can completely break the engine wich will also stop the other workflows running in parallel along with the faulted one. This is a big issue when running unmanaged code, where memory access violations or any other severe exception will crash the process. Writing the correct infrastructure to handle this situation is not trivial.

Many business problems are easily modeled using workflows, specially now that asynchronous transactions have been improved in this beta release. And WWF supports many (if not all) of the common workflow patterns. State machine workflows seems to be hard to implement with this release but I haven’t look into this yet.

You can find more info at the Windows Workflow Foundation for .Net 4 developer center:

More on workflow patterns here:



You may already know Aspect-oriented programming and how further decouple non business logic from the model. .Net has been using this paradigm across various frameworks like WCF by using attributes. Reflection has been for me the only reasonable way to exploit these attributes so far, which means the behavior is changed in runtime (which also added complexity). You also had to write down how this attributes are handled which didn’t help concentrating code.

PostSharp is a true AOP helper here, letting you completely describe the business and adorn the fields, methods and classes with .Net attributes. During a post-build step, the assembly is injected with some code based on those attributes. The aspects are encapsulated as attributes freeing the team from writing tons of repetitive lines. Decoupling aspects from the main logic also encourages code reutilization and increases maintainability by unifying scattered code in just one place. Although sometimes finding current crosscutting concerns in the code, or taking the effort to re-implement them as aspects can be overwhelming at first.

PostSharp 2.0 has gone even further allowing dependency solving which is something very promising (although its license may change).